Caribbean Court upholds trade ministerial decision on cement classification

Last Updated on Tuesday, 6 August 2019, 21:23 by Writer

The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) on Tuesday delivered a judgement which upholds the classification decision of the CARICOM Council for Trade and Economic Development (COTED) on cement, known as Rock Hard Cement, imported and/or distributed within CARICOM by Rock Hard Cement (Rock Hard Distributors Limited) and, Mootilal Ramhit and Sons Contracting Limited.

These proceedings in the CCJ’s Original Jurisdiction mark the finale of complex litigation which has resulted in five separate judgements and numerous orders thus far.

Tuesday’s judgement settled the dispute as to whether Rock Hard Cement ought to be classified as ‘Building cement (grey)’ and be charged a CARICOM tax of 15% when imported into the region, or as ‘Other hydraulic cement’ in which case a levy of 0-5% would be payable. Earlier this year, COTED decided that Rock Hard Cement was to be classified as ‘Other hydraulic cement’ in line with the advice received from the World Customs Organization’s (‘WCO’) Harmonized System (‘HS’) Committee.

The State of Trinidad and Tobago, Trinidad Cement Limited (TCL) and Arawak Cement Company Limited argued that COTED’s decision-making process was procedurally flawed and that COTED’s reliance on the WCO’s advice went against the economic objectives of the CARICOM tax. On this basis they contended that Rock Hard Cement should be classified as ‘Building cement (grey)’ and be subjected to the 15% tax as Rock Hard Cement was in direct competition with TCL’s regionally produced ‘Building cement (grey)’.

In its judgement, the CCJ upheld the COTED classification decision as being binding on all Member States in keeping with Article 29(1) of the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas (RTC). The Court found that COTED was fully entitled to place heavy reliance upon the WCO advice, given the role of the WCO in harmonizing rules on international trade within the context of the World Trade Organization (WTO).

While it upheld the COTED classification decision, the Court also commented that recent developments in the cement industry made it appropriate for a study to be done by COTED to assess whether the tariff rate for imported ‘Other hydraulic cement’ ought to be increased to give additional protection to regional cement manufacturers in order to obtain an appropriate level of protection.

The Court indicated that the conduct of such a study would be entirely in keeping with the CARICOM Treaty obligation on COTED to keep the tariff under review (Article 83 (5) of the RTC). The CCJ also recommended greater collaboration in undertaking global trade commitments, as in their commitments to the WTO, and it suggested the implementation of a project aimed at harmonizing the classification of goods based on WCO standards in a move to increase CARICOM trade.

This judgement was delivered for the consolidated matters of Trinidad Cement Limited and The State of Trinidad and Tobago and Rock Hard Distribution Limited and Mootilal Ramhit and Sons Contracting Limited, Trinidad Cement Limited & Arawak Cement Company Limited and The State of Barbados and Rock Hard Cement Limited, Rock Hard Cement Limited and The State of Barbados and The Caribbean Community, and Rock Hard Distribution Limited and The State of Trinidad and Tobago and The Caribbean Community.