Last Updated on Saturday, 21 November 2026, 4:25 by Written By Denis Chabrol

Attorney-at-Law Christopher Ram on Friday protested the decision by the MV Barima Commission of Inquiry (COI) to bar him from examining the families during the probe on the basis that that is the job of lawyers for the commission.
Mr Ram said that decision to restrict his participation as lawyer for the families affected by the MV Barima disaster that occurred on July 18 to preparing witness statements and making closing submission, while reserving examination of his clients to lawyers for the commission, was communicated to him by COI Chairman Retired Godfrey Smith in a letter dated November 18.
“I hereby notify the Commission that I am not prepared to accept these conditions as being the best interest of my clients who have retained me to represent their interests in an investigation into a tragedy in which their loved ones died or remain missing,” Mr Ram told Mr Smith in a letter dated November 18, 2026. Though he is refusing to represent the families when they appear before the commission, Mr Ram said that should not be interpreted to mean that they would not be appearing before the five-member probe team appointed by the president. “This should not be construed as a withdrawal by those persons from the Inquiry, an abandonment
of their interests, or a waiver of any rights or remedies available to them,” he said.
Mr Ram said effective representation involves more than preparing witness statements and commenting upon evidence after it has been taken. Rather, he said it includes the opportunity to present their evidence, seek clarification, address matters arising during examination and ensure that material issues affecting their interests are properly explored.
The lawyer told the COI Chairman that under the arrangements prescribed by the Commission, lawyers for the Commission would determine how his clients’ evidence is presented, which matters are pursued and what questions are asked. Mr Ram said the commission’s lawyers have responsibilities to the Commission as a whole and does not represent the particular interests of his clients. “Those responsibilities cannot be equated with the professional obligations of independently retained counsel. Closing submissions cannot remedy material omissions or deficiencies in evidence already taken,” he said.
He recalled that the 2014 presidential commission of inquiry into the June 1980 assassination of Working People’s Alliance co-founder Dr Walter Rodney had allowed lawyers to lead and re-examine their own witnesses. He said that Commission demonstrated that meaningful participation by independently retained counsel was entirely compatible with the Commission’s authority to regulate its proceedings. He said COI chairman Godfrey Smith’s public commitment “Wherever the evidence leads we go,” was particularly relevant to the present Inquiry.” I find it difficult to reconcile the restrictions now imposed with either that procedural precedent or the principle of thorough and independent investigation which it exemplified,” he said.
The lawyer, a prominent civil society activist who has challenged several Guyana government’s policies, said he recognised the Commission’s authority to regulate its proceedings but said that did not “oblige me to accept a role which, in my considered professional judgment, reduces my clients’ right to independent legal representation to something largely formal rather than substantive.”
Mr Ram also raised serious concerns about the prolonged delay in recovering the vessel, the consequences for the preservation of critical evidence and the additional suffering of affected families. The three-page letter also questions any limitation on the examination of policymakers, including members of the political directorate responsible for decisions affecting the vessel’s maintenance, replacement and continued operation.
Discover more from Demerara Waves Online News- Guyana
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.




