Last Updated on Friday, 20 November 2026, 19:38 by Written By Denis Chabrol
By Surendra Dhanpaul
In light of recent reports that the United States has floated the idea of renewed negotiations, I hereby call upon the U.S. State Department to withdraw any suggestion that new boundary arrangements can be brokered.
The United States has already played its role in helping to facilitate a settlement between Britain and Venezuela. Contrary to Venezuela’s claim before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) that it was not adequately represented or privy to arbitration proceedings, Guyana has strongly argued that Venezuela knowingly participated in the process. The United States itself cites this arbitration as a key historical milestone, noting that “Venezuela enthusiastically submitted to arbitration.” See: https://history.state.gov/milestones/1866-1898/venezuela
Furthermore, under the principle of uti possidetis juris (“as you possess under law”), newly independent states inherit the administrative boundaries that existed at the time of independence. The matter is currently before the ICJ and, given America’s historical role in the original process, it should not encourage or entertain the prospect of new territorial negotiations.
Guyana is demonstrably more politically stable than Venezuela. In recent years, regardless of which political party has held office, American companies have been able to conduct business in Guyana with confidence. Venezuela, by contrast, has experienced prolonged political instability and governance challenges that have complicated its relationship with the United States and the international community. Guyana, meanwhile, continues to function as a democratic state with a market-based economy and remains a reliable partner for international investment.
Guyana’s history is also distinguished by cooperation and trade with its Indigenous peoples. Unlike the Spanish and Portuguese colonial systems that devastated many Indigenous societies through conquest, enslavement, and dispossession after Columbus’ arrival in the Americas, the Dutch relationship with Indigenous communities in what is now Guyana was characterized largely by trade and mutual exchange rather than large-scale subjugation. This relationship has been further strengthened through legislative protections such as the Amerindian Act No. 6 of 2006, which establishes a clear administrative framework recognizing Indigenous rights and governance. See: https://parliament.gov.gy/documents/acts/4680-act_no_6_of_2006.pdf
Guyana’s Amerindian Act provides a clear administrative framework that empowers Indigenous communities through recognized village governance, land rights, and participation in national development. By contrast, Indigenous communities in Venezuela continue to face threats from illegal mining, environmental destruction, and inadequate state protection even though Venezuela enacted its own protections for indigenous people. The difference is clear: Guyana has sought to build institutions that empower Indigenous peoples, whereas Venezuela has too often failed to provide effective safeguards for the communities it claims to protect.
Humpty Dumpty serves as a useful metaphor for trust and legitimacy. Once broken, they cannot simply be restored to their original form. The international rules-based order depends upon the principle that settled boundaries and legal agreements remain respected. Reopening issues that have already been adjudicated risks undermining confidence in international institutions and established legal processes.
Guyana remains open to trade, investment, and cooperation with the United States. These realities stand in sharp contrast to the challenges that continue to characterize Venezuela’s relationship with the United States, the broader international community, and its own citizens.
Finally, I call once more on the United States, through its Department of State, to publicly withdraw any suggestion that the border is up for negotiations and respect its own role previously played
Discover more from Demerara Waves Online News- Guyana
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.




