Internet Radio

Deputy Solicitor General complains to Public Service Commission about Attorney General

Prithima Kissoon (Guyana Chronicle photo)

Guyana’s Deputy Solicitor General, Prithima Kissoon has accused Attorney General and Minister of Legal Affairs, Basil Williams of frustrating her out office  by refusing to cooperate with her on several cases while at the same time publicly questioning her performance.

Repeated efforts to contact the Attorney General on his mobile phone proved futile.

Kissoon, who has worked with three Attorneys General since February 2013, has since written to the Public Service Commission (PSC), lodging complaints against Williams. Those letters have been copied to Minister of State, Joseph Harmon.

“Commissioners, I respectfully wish to inform you that the course of conduct administered unlawfully by the AG personally upon me are reprehensible, unbearable and malicious, initiated and executed by the AG, Basil Williams SC, so that I leave the office which I consider through the opinion of my lawyers as constructive dismissal,” she told the PSC in  the letter dispatched last week.

Kissoon wants the PSC to approve her deferred leave from 2016 to allow that constitutional body to “find a remedy  in the circumstances” and approval for her to leave Guyana.

She said she has evidence to prove that although she has been repeatedly preparing legal documents for the Attorney General to approve in relation to pending matters, the Attorney General has been less than cooperative.

“In Court matters draft opinions/pleadings are presented to the AG, Mr. Basil Williams, for approval, signature, correction or alteration and even though reminded regularly this is not done or is done so belatedly and at the ninth hour that I have been embarrassed before the Courts or had to resort to my legal acumen to ensure that the State is properly represented,” she said in her letter addressed to the Secretary of the PSC.

The Deputy Solicitor General charged that on occasions when legal matters do arise in Court, in which she appears in the majority of cases, although the Attorney General in writing, undertakes to the Court to appear and conduct the matters he does not do so or his appearance is merely cursory.

Kissoon further charged that the  Attorney General has failed to approve or sign written submissions prepared by her  or examine pleadings despite those documents being sent to him via email or being given to his Confidential Secretary, Ms. Demi Hipplewith, Ms. Andrea Marks and other assistants he has retained over the past year.

Kissoon said the Attorney General has has since instructed Ms. Hipplewith and his other assistants to refuse to accept any documents or correspondences from her and “as a result, I have had to resort to registering or express mailing him my correspondences and at all times emailing him and carbon copying relevant recipients.”

“Kindly be informed, that on numerous occasions the Attorney General requests adjournments for matters and despite the Honourable Courts adjourning matters to accommodate the AG, he has continued not to give instructions or examine documents prepared by me before they are filed or presented to the Cour,” she added.

The Deputy Solicitor General said relations further deteriorated on January 19, 2017 when the Attorney General “wrongfully and unlawfully” that she and Chancellor of the Judiciary, Carl Singh conspired to aid Opposition Leader Bharrat Jagdeo in the case of the Attorney General vs Bharrat Jagdeo. She said it was the Full Bench of the Court of Appeal  that dismissed the Appeal, filed by the former Solicitor General, after a Motion was filed by Mr. Murseline Bacchus seeking to have the appeal that was improperly intituled, dismissed as an abuse of process of the Court. “I can assure you that such utterances in the press are without factual basis and indeed created an action of libel against his victims who were named in the Chronicle,” she said.

In a separate letter on January 23, 2017, the Deputy Solicitor General told the Attorney General that “You have sought to besmirch and vilify my character and impeach my integrity, hoping that your harassment of me in the Office and now in the public domain by the aforesaid publication will cause me to abandon my Office and vacate same,” she said in the letter that was copied to Attorney-at-Law, Jailall Kissoon, the Secretary to the PSC and Minister of State and Public Service, Harmon.

“In the aforesaid matter the AG though notified of a motion filed by Mr Bacchus in which I appeared and which required an Affidavit in Answer to be filed by the AG, as he was the named appellant: this was not done even though I diligently prepared a draft Affidavit and presented same to him he did not see it fit to peruse or discuss or give me instructions on same.  I have records to show my notification and reminders to him,” she added.

Whilst this step, that is to have the Affidavit in Answer filed, was not taken to satisfy the procedure of the Court, the Court continued to fix a date for the hearing of the matter. Adjourned dates are continued to be given in which I have to appear and I am duty bound to the Court who enquire about my course of action.  In the Attorney General v Bharrat Jagdeo, I sought to make oral submissions which were put in writing and sent to the Court as well as copied to the AG.

Kissoon said she has since been instructed by the Permanent Secretary to cease  conduct of all court matters involving the AG Chambers until further notice, and on the 23rd of January, 2017, “I received a further memo questioning my conduct as to the non filing of the Affidavit in answer in the case of AG v BJ.”

“On the 24th Jan, 2017, in pursuance of AG further humiliating me and seeking to find a reason lawful or unlawful to oust me from my post he sent members of his Admin staff to record from my office all the cases that are contained therein, whatsoever that means I don’t know for I deal only in court cases, for which all pleadings and documents are a matter of public record, having been filed,” she said.

  • Gtloyal

    Of course there are three sides to a story; in this case, his, hers and the truth. If the above is anywhere near the truth, however, the AG must be told, bluntly, that this is not the way to do things. It will appear credible to many because we have seen these childish behavior repeated time and time again by the ministers of the Granger led government, to the extent that it must be embarrassing to him by now. I can’t believe that he can’t see the damage that is being done. They seem to be lacking in worldly wisdom or informed judgment.
    Don’t they know better or is it intentional?

    • Col123

      It is the ethnic superiority complex with the AG …it is a disease without a cure is not childish behavior!

      • Gtloyal

        What brings you to the conclusion that it is ” ethnic superiority complex “? Give specific, logical reasons from the case that leads you to say this.

        • Col123

          GT: There isn’t any good reason to convince any loyalist who exhibited similar demeanor in his past comments?…

          • Gtloyal

            “There isn’t any good reason to ….”
            There you are. You say it because you know it’s so. It’s you and your kind who can’t do without mentioning ethnicity. Unfortunately, embedded racist feelings always seem to get the better of you guys. Get over it. There are other reasons that, if you stop to think and identify them, may even help you to figure out why you are on the wrong side of the aisle.

  • Lancelot Brassington

    I guess we will never know the whole truth. It could well be that there are other facts that suggest that the good lady has been undermining efforts directed against members of the past administration . It could well be that she is not as professional as she ought to be. On the other hand it could be that she is blameless.
    What I know for sure is that Basil Williams’ approach to this matter leaves a lot to be desired. This guy is all about hysteria. This was demonstrated in the Rodney COI. He seems to have no regard for procedure and his actions do not seem to be properly thought out. He is rash and reckless. I wouldn’t have thought that he was Granger’s type but I guess that failure to appoint him would have created a firestorm within the PNC.
    Williams would do well to develop some craft, cunning and finesse and try to do justice to the status of senior counsel. The picture of a male attorney general having a go at a female subordinate is not a pleasant one.

    • Col123

      Agree with comments ..but you are giving the AG too much respect…. the upside is the young lady is holding on her own…makes me supportive of her stance.

  • Col123

    It is refreshing to see a young woman who appears to be following the procedures, taking on the AG…

  • Fedup / GT

    Demararawave, what happen to my post?

  • brain dead idiot

    so according to the AG you can’t be ppp supporter and work with government well well mr paterson was with the AFC and working with the ppp government and many others is the ag going mad he need some help